Civil disputes in India cover a broad spectrum of disputes arising between people, entities or organizations related to rights, obligations and liabilities. These disputes may take the form of property disputes, breaches of contract, family disputes, or monetary claims. Civil disputes occur in everyday life and among friends and businesses and are no surprise as the modern personal and commercial relationships become more complex, documentation is unavailable or dated, and delays in communication or compliance put strain on relationships.
It is important to know your available legal remedies and to consult with a lawyer early on to avoid escalation or prolonged resolution times. With the benefits of experience, a civil lawyer can guide individuals and businesses through the legal processes, act on their behalf to protect their rights, and ultimately either negotiate or argue at trial for a fair resolution. You can visit Prime Legal to consult one of the best civil lawyers.
What Are Civil Disputes?
A civil dispute is a disagreement among two or more parties that relates to a violation of private rights, duties, or obligations. In India, these disputes are mostly regulated by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), which defines procedure for filing civil cases, hearing them in court, and ultimately deciding the case.
Civil disputes are different from criminal cases because a State (or regulator) is prosecuting someone for committing an act against the State or society, while civil disputes resolve private conflict, and compensate or provide specific relief to the injured party, not punishing the offender. The main difference between civil and criminal disputes is in the nature of the dispute and the outcome:
Civil disputes relate to private wrongs (breaches of contract, property disputes), which are different from criminal disputes that are accusations against a public wrong (theft, assault), and the outcome of a civil dispute is restoration of rights or compensating losses.
Common types of civil disputes that one may experience day to day include the following:
- A landlord-tenant dispute regarding rent or eviction of the tenant;
- A boundary or ownership dispute with a neighbour;
- A breach of contract between seller and buyer;
- Matrimonial disputes such as divorce or maintenance claims;
- Collection of a loan not paid.
Common Types of Civil Disputes in India
Civil disputes in India can take many forms and they occur in one’s personal or occupational life. Knowing the forms of civil disputes can help an individual understand what their rights are and to receive relief in a timely fashion. The most common types of disputes are in the nature of the following:
- Property Disputes
- Contractual Disputes
- Family Disputes
- Consumer Disputes
- Defamation Cases
- Landlords and Tenants
1. Property Disputes
These are some of the most common civil disputes, which concern ownership rights, possession, the division of ancestral property, and encroachment on property rights by illegal possession. Property disputes commonly arise from disputes regarding title or ownership claims as it relates to inheritance.
2. Contractual Disputes
These arise as we see when one party is not compliant with the terms of a contract (either in writing or oral) as we see in, non-payment of a loan, or unfulfilled business agreement, for example not delivering parcels on time.
3. Family Disputes
Types of family disputes include divorce, child custody, maintenance, and inheritance claims. Family courts and mediation centers typically address family disputes with the goal of obtaining fair and humane outcomes.
4. Consumer Disputes
Consumers are faced with disputes when they are either a defective product, a service that is not of equal quality, or when an unfair trade practice has occurred. A consumer can approach an application through the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, by filing a claim through a consumer forum and, in many instances, online. Learn more about our consumer law services.
5. Defamation Cases
Concern injury to someone’s reputation from a false statement either in spoken (slander) or written (libel) form.
6. Landlords and Tenants
Commonly seen in urban areas when a tenant gets evicted, or is in rent arrears, or violating a lease with a landlord.
For expert assistance in resolving product or service-related disputes, explore our consumer law services to understand your rights and legal options.
Legal Options for Civil Disputes
Depending on the nature of the dispute, whether a person or entity seeks, or the desired result, there are several potential legal options available to people and entities in India for resolving civil disputes. The remedy selected may depend upon which of the parties processes looks like a court or alternative dispute resolution.
a) Civil Suit in the Courts:
The easiest legal option, and the one, which is most of the time, used to resolve civil disputes is to simply file a civil suit with a proper court jurisdiction under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). Generally, the process will begin with a person (plaintiff) filing a lawsuit, filing all requested documents and evidence, participating in court hearings for a court a decision, and the process, hopefully, ends with a judgment. Upon a judgment the court may issue remedies, such as an injunction, award damages, or enforce specific performance on a contract.
b) Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR):
Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) consists of methods, such as mediation, arbitration and conciliation. Such mechanisms are much quicker and less expensive options than traditional litigation. All methods ultimately focus on resolution and discussion to resolve the dispute outside of the courts-
- Mediation: Like ADR the parties will hire a neutral third party to assist them in reaching a mutually acceptable agreement.
- Arbitration: A private tribunal will issue a decision which will bind the parties in the same manner as a court decree.
- Conciliation: While conciliation is like mediation, the conciliator will be more proactive in suggesting terms of settlement.
c) Negotiations and Settlements Options:
Before or during the course of court proceedings, the parties can negotiate the matter directly and reach a mutual settlement, which can also be recorded before the court.
If you’re facing a legal conflict, our dispute resolution services in Bangalore can help you achieve effective and timely settlements through mediation, arbitration, or litigation
Methods to Settle Civil Disputes Outside of Court
Civil disputes may be resolved faster, cheaper and less acrimoniously without going through a court process. Settling the matter in a non-litigated manner may often preserve the parties’ relationship and may allow time for the grievance to be resolved through discussion and consensus. Below are the typical methods of resolution:
1. Send A Legal Notice
The first step in the civil dispute process is to send the other party a duly constituted notice, setting out the grievance, remedy sought, and a reasonable time to respond or comply. The legal notices serve as a formal notice and often triggers settlement discussions, or could trigger a complete avoidance of court litigation proceedings. To learn more you can visit our blog on ‘How to Send a Legal Notice in India’.
2. Mediation or Arbitration
If discussions have failed either party could suggest Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) procedures, such as Mediation or Arbitration. Mediation includes a neutral mediator who will oversee the conversation, while each side will participate in their resolution. Arbitration is slightly different in that the parties agree to appoint an Arbitrator to resolve the dispute and the Arbitrator’s decision (award) is binding and enforceable as provided in law.
3. Create a Settlement Agreement
Once the parties reach agreement, they must prepare a written settlement agreement which clearly records all obligations, timelines and consequences for non-compliance. Further, the agreement can be placed before a Court or arbitral tribunal to confirm it as enforceable by law.
Following these steps will, in most situations, allow the disputing parties to resolve a dispute in a fair manner and more quickly than full litigation, which can often be expensive and delayed.
To understand the legal procedure in detail, check out our comprehensive guide on how to file a civil case in India for step-by-step instructions and expert tips.
When to Turn to a Civil Court
While ideally, settlement negotiations or mediation is preferable, sometimes a party must engage in civil action to protect their rights. Except in exceptional situations, when mediation or negotiation culminates in no outcome that is acceptable for all parties, your recourse is into a civil court.
1. After Settlement Options Have Failed
Parties have attempted to negotiate, mediate, arbitrate a reasonable without success, now it may be time to explore the options of a civil suit to pursue judicial relief. Civil court proceedings provide the parties with the opportunity to have the court resolve the dispute within the framework of evidence, law and fairness.
2. When there is a Dispute Regarding Rights or Ownership
Civil courts play an important role in disputes about ownership, possession and/or contractual rights – i.e., rights of ownership, joint venture partners or intellectual property rights. The court’s decision is fetched with finality and recognition of those ownership or rights.
3. When there is a Need for an Urgent Injunction
When one party needs to act swiftly in order to prevent another party from taking action – for example, the sale of property in dispute, publication of defamatory material or breach of an agreement – an aggrieved party may seek relief from the court in an interim or permanent form of an injunction. Courts are able to make orders to avoid irreparable harm.
The Role of Civil Lawyers in Dispute Resolution
Civil lawyers are essential in ensuring that disputes are resolved efficiently, in accordance with the law, and in a way that achieves the best result for the client. Civil lawyers work with clients from preliminary consultation and give advice, to representing the client in court, alternative dispute resolution or settlement.
1. Document and Legal Position Review
Civil lawyers will start by reviewing all relevant contracts, property documents, correspondence, & evidence to analyze the client’s legal position. This will help to establish both the strengths and weaknesses of the party’s case to help determine the appropriate legal strategy for the matter.
2. Advice on Settlement or Litigation
The obligations of a civil lawyer will then provide their client with advice as to whether the dispute may be resolved through negotiation, mediation or arbitration (alternative dispute resolution), or whether a civil suit should proceed in court. The civil lawyer’s job is to secure a fair remedy while minimizing cost and delay.
3. Mediation or Court Representation and Legal Documents
Civil lawyers, in circumstances where matters are mediated or the dispute moves to the court, will represent and advocate on behalf of their clients during the mediation or trial. Civil lawyers take on all procedural requirements of the process and advocates associated with the matter, including drafting pleadings, settlement agreements and appeals. If you’re seeking professional legal representation, consult the best civil lawyers in Bangalore for expert advice and effective dispute resolution.
Recommendations to Avoid Civil Disputes
It is better to avoid litigation wherever possible, as you’ll find. Reasonably prudent documentation, communication and an understanding of one’s obligations can reduce the chances of civil disputes, in a number of specific areas:
1. Document All Agreements in Writing
Be sure to receive written confirmations of all working business or personal relationships that will specify your rights, duties and/the effective date, in a formal document. Oral contracts have legal standing and should be documented in written form as proof of contractual negotiations. Read about oral vs. written contracts in another section of the site.
2. Document Property Transactions Correctly
Be sure there is all sale deeds, leases or other evidence of ownership on file and/or registered correctly to avoid future disputes over ownership or possession. Having an attorney or legal expert verify ownership before a purchase is encouraged.
3. Keep Communication Records
Always keep emails, letters, messages and receipts of payments for any transaction or agreements. These will be invaluable evidence should the issue ever become an issue.
These practical recommendations will best protect your interests and reduce the chances of litigation or civil disputes that will become costly and time-consuming.
Conclusion
Civil disputes are a fact of life in the modern world, whether due to miscommunication, breach of contract, or some unclear ownership right. Education regarding the underlying legal principles, the available remedies, and the role of civil lawyers will prepare individuals to deal with these disputes.
Involving a legal professional early in a dispute can assist in resolving the issue both quickly and amicably, and to prevent the likelihood of conflict from boiling over. Do not hesitate to consult with Prime Legal civil law experts for services offering professional assistance and solutions for a legal dispute or for preventative legal advice.
FAQs
1. What are the most common types of civil disputes in India?
Typically, the most common types of civil disputes pertain to disputes regarding property, contract violations or breaches, family disputes, consumer disputes, and disputes related to tenancy.
2. How can civil disputes be resolved without going to court?
A party can utilize one of the Alternative Dispute Resolution methods such as mediation, arbitration, or conciliation to resolve the matter peacefully and without wasting time.
3. When should I file a civil suit in court?
A party should go to court when negotiation and settlement attempts have failed or if the party wants the court to enforce or protect their legal rights or ownership.
4. Do I need a lawyer to handle a civil dispute?
Yes, a civil lawyer can assist you with evaluating your civil case, preparing the documents that you will need for civil proceedings, and assist you in determining whether to negotiate and settle the issues or litigate in a court of law.
Schedule Your Consultation
Legal problems can be stressful—we’re here to make it easier.
